Middle-earth: Shadow of Mordor Review

Let’s not beat around the bush: you’re interested in the Nemesis system. Without wishing to sound harsh, I can’t say I’m surprised; it really is the one unique and special thing that Middle-earth: Shadow of Mordor has going for it. This is the system that means the mini-bosses you’ll face throughout the game grow and evolve based on your actions, gaining in power and becoming more lethal if they escape your assaults or defeat you themselves.

It’s a clever system, and it is absolutely the lynchpin of Shadow of Mordor. I cannot overstate that enough: without that system and the way it impacts the game, this would otherwise be an adequate but uninspired Lord of the Rings-themed take on Assassin’s Creed.

Shadow of Mordor - 07 - 2
This guy was a thorn in my side for awhile, not least because he actually came BACK after the first time I killed him.

You play as Talion, a deceased ranger made immortal by an elven wraith. After his family was butchered by the Black Hand of Sauron, Talion woke up to find himself bound to a wraith, and – as seems sensible in the situation – he’s now roaming Mordor in search of both revenge, and a means of breaking the curse so that he can finally die. All of which is done via the same free-roaming pseudo-stealth as Assassin’s Creed.

The fact that Talion cannot die, though, plays heavily into the game’s mechanics. If you’re “killed” then you wake up at the nearest fast travel point (Assassin’s Creed-like giant towers, and yes, they reveal the surrounding area and the quests within)… but it’s not an undo button. Things change when you die. Time passes.

The enemy that killed you? Well, they probably just became a captain. If they were a captain already, then they’ve become stronger and more powerful. If other captains were getting on with other events, like recruitment or hunting, then they’ll either have died or also become stronger. Even failing changes the way the world works.

Shadow of Mordor - 23 - 2
Shadow of Mordor is significantly more brutal than Assassin’s Creed or Batman, mind you. Those games don’t usually feature decapitations or exploding heads.

There’s a lot of fun you can have with this system, too. Talion has three fighting styles: there’s his skill with a sword in direct combat, his archery, and his stealth. Sword combat is basically Batman: Mordor Asylum, insofar as you try to build up a big hit chain, and enemies have giant COUNTER-ATTACK NOW prompts above their heads. Archery temporarily slows everything to a crawl so that you can aim properly on a gamepad. Stealth lets you instantly kill a target either by sneaking up behind them, or dropping onto them from above, or dragging them off a ledge, or whatever.

But the different captains and warchiefs you face have different resistances, different weaknesses, different abilities, and different fears. This guy might be completely immune to stealth and ranged, so you’ve got no choice but to face him in direct combat… but he’s also scared of fire, so you can use that knowledge to turn him into a quivering, whimpering, fleeing wreck. This other guy’s a complete monster in a direct fight, taking no damage from your counter-attacks and immune to most of your other little tricks, but a single attack from stealth will instantly kill him.

Shadow of Mordor - 24 - 2
Wasn’t kidding.

So you learn. You wait for the appropriate opportunity to strike, and then you descend in a storm of blood and swords, and tick off another target from your handy Uruk-hai Organisational Chart. Or something goes horribly, horribly wrong, and you’ve just made your opponent tougher to take on the next time.

Shadow of Mordor thrives on unexpected shit ruining your plans. You might’ve spent a few minutes moving steadily and stealthily into position to assassinate an unaware captain, and then suddenly a pack of murdercats (sorry; I mean “Caragor”) leap into the fray, start slaughtering Uruk-hai left and right, and then sniff you out and come for you. If you’re infiltrating a stronghold, then an alarm might get tripped and suddenly you’re not just taking on one guy and his guards; you’re taking on a continually-spawning set of very angry green men. You can’t plan for everything.

Shadow of Mordor - 09 - 2
Seemingly simple battles can get a bit messy when roaming beasts join in.

If you played the first Assassin’s Creed, the easiest way I can sum up the open-world Orc-murdering is to say it’s basically what that should have been. You can interrogate captains and “worms” to get details on where to find others and what their strengths and weaknesses are, but you don’t have to. When assassinating a warchief (the biggest and baddest enemies, aside from the game’s scripted bosses) you can deal with their bodyguard captains first to make things easier, but you don’t have to. It’s your choice whether you want to find information and make things easier for yourself, or just recklessly hurl yourself into danger.

It’s an excellent system, and when it works, it’s glorious and spectacular and emergent, which is easily one of my favourite adjectives. Unfortunately, that’s when it works, and there are problems. Quite a few of them, in fact.

For one thing, there’s all the fluff surrounding the Nemesis system. The voice-acting is great, but the story itself is uninteresting drivel and there are maybe two likeable characters throughout the entire game. The boss battles are pants, and the story missions themselves tend to be a tad repetitive. The game also visibly shoehorns you into playing with the Nemesis system, insofar as you have to interact with it in order to finish each of the game’s two major areas. I like the system, but I don’t like being roadblocked until I’ve messed with it in a game-required way.

Shadow of Mordor - 05 - 2
Judging by that mission description, Goroth the Knife finally won the war on DRUGS. I can see why he became a captain; the Uruks are notoriously law-and-order focused.

There’s the upgrade system, which is a little overcomplicated. You obtain upgrades through experience (which unlocks new abilities), Mirian (which generally improves Talion’s attributes, like maximum health) and Runes (which are affixed to your weapons and provide various buffs). A random rune is dropped every time you kill a captain or warchief, and the theory is that they let you customise your playstyle how you like.

The problem is that they rapidly become confusing. This rune gives you a 27% chance to gain +5 health on a critical hit, while this one offers a 40% chance to regain 30% Focus on a headshot from your bow, and this other one offers you a 72% chance to get two extra arrows when you perform a Brutalise stealth kill, and this fourth rune gives a 17% chance for Talion to dance the fandango when you successfully complete a quicktime event. I may have made one of those up, but… uh, wait, how do I get my health back again?

With each weapon able to hold five runes – for a total of fifteen equipped runes at once, if you fully upgrade your rune slots – you will very, very quickly forget which action triggers what buff. Which is a bit of a problem when you’re in the midst of an all-out brawl with 20 Uruk-hai and you really need to regain some Focus so that you can snap off a few arrows.

Shadow of Mordor - 17 - 2
Meet Torvin, a dwarf with the honour of being one of the very few entertaining characters in the game.

The final big issue is actually the Nemesis system itself, insofar as you actually have to put in quite a lot of effort to make it work the way it’s supposed to. Early on, I encountered the same captain three or four times, and I could never quite kill the bastard.

Then I killed the bastard, and while every captain from then on was a unique little snowflake with their own stats and attributes, none of them really stuck in my mind. They were just a target who had to be killed in a different way.

This reached its head towards the end of the storyline, when I had a climactic showdown with my own unique, personalised Nemesis! Who was someone I don’t think I’d ever actually met before, because I’d become sufficiently skilled by that point that no captain ever survived an encounter with me. Deflated the situation somewhat, that.

Shadow of Mordor - 16 - 2
Shadow of Mordor does, however, have a really nice line in picturesque vistas for you to free-run and climb around. Who knew Mordor looked this nice? Not me, but then I’d never heard of Núrn.

Which is sort of the problem. Middle-earth: Shadow of Mordor is a game with a lot of clever ideas and fun systems, but they don’t quite mesh together to form a cohesive game, nor do they work tremendously well on their own unless you’re willing to put in quite a lot of effort to, say, deliberately not kill your Nemesis. You don’t unlock the really entertaining powers (which let you bend Uruks to your will and really screw with their army composition) until about 60% through the story, and that’s also around the time you’ll probably have figured out enough of the systems that the game stops presenting any real sort of challenge.

But… I don’t really want to leave it like that, because Shadow of Mordor is a tremendously polished game which occasionally hits moments of genuine greatness. It’s got better stealth than Assassin’s Creed, some fun lore points, entertainingly brutal combat, and a lot of really good ideas. (It’s also one of the finest PC ports in recent memory; seriously, the porting job here is really, really good.) It’s just that most of those ideas need a bit more work to actually form something spectacular, because as it stands, Shadow of Mordor feels a little bit… empty. It’s popcorn gaming: entertaining, but not even remotely filling. Fingers crossed for these ideas to coalesce better in a sequel or another title, basically.

A highly polished and generally entertaining romp, but it's missing a vital spark to bring everything together.

Tim McDonald

Tim has been playing PC games for longer than he’s willing to admit. He’s written for a number of publications, but has been with PC Invasion – in all its various incarnations – for over a decade. When not writing about games, Tim can occasionally be found speedrunning terrible ones, making people angry in Dota 2, or playing something obscure and random. He’s also weirdly proud of his status as (probably) the Isle of Man’s only professional games journalist.

  • USMC03Vet

    What does the “world” consist of? All I’ve seen so far is walls, dirt, and a bush here and there. Are there towns? A living world? I think I saw a half naked man run by the screen once oblivious to the 50 Orcs fighting a super hero on Angry Joe’s stream.

    Diablo 3 did the nemesis system and now this game. I hope this trend continues because it’s a nice thing that adds to the game. I’d love this sort of thing in the next Elder Scrolls or for that matter Fallout game. Mordor could have been epic if it had a world to it I think. I’d probably kill somebody for combat mechanics like this in an Elder Scrolls game.

    No modding is a drag. Having open world games without it is almost a crime these days.

    • lazerbeak

      yeah I totally agree about that it would be uber cool if skyrim had decent combat

  • lazerbeak

    Did you try the HD texture pack?

  • lazerbeak

    I liked the dwarf too do you ever find why he has no beard?

  • lazerbeak

    I played the game a lot now 60 percent though and I have I am getting bored could be just me though the I have a very short attention span and get bored real easy,

    Saying that I didn’t stop playing Batman AC until I completed it and I did it on hard too.

    The game seems to have got very repetitive , the story isnt very compelling in fact I don’t understand it even though I am a LOTR geek and have read the book multiple times.

    The ” nemesis system” is probably the only really interesting thing about the game. The fighting is ok but I don’t find it as satisfying as the batman games even though technically its similar.

    The quests are ALL kill this orc, mind control this orc…orc orc orc

    The bosses are just matter of finding the weakness and exploiting them but the end of the day its just another orc in fancy armor,

    You can collect herb, kill wildlife and collect relics whichs is kinda interesting I suppose.

    The orcs are not very smart even for orcs, you only have to climb up high and they lose interest in you.

    Even if you have slaughtered dozens of them.

    Saying all that its worth playing IMHO but I would advise waiting for a cheap price.

    There’s probably better out there for 30 pounds.

  • Nathan Merrill

    I have to more or less agree with this review; the nemesis system was a brilliant idea, but it was strapped on the back of a game which is really only barely adequete. When Assassins’ Creed shines, it shines much brighter than this game, and I felt like Batman: Arkham Asylum executed the combat and stealth better than this game did.

    Really, I would love to see some other game use the Nemesis system, and do so with better gameplay. The story is meh and the missions are mostly meh, and on the whole it is not as good a game as the better AC entries.

  • Nathan Merrill

    Yeah, the game is definitely repetitive, and has issues with it.

    Honestly, all the game has going for it is the nemesis system; the level design is not great, combat becomes rote by the middle of the game, and the overall difficulty level on the game is very low. Combined with a lot of fairly tedious quests, pretty much identical sidequests (seriously, saving slaves tied to poles 24 times?), a cast of characters you don’t care about at all, and a story which isn’t engaging and you don’t really have a whole lot.

    Some game is going to make great use of a nemesis-like system, but Shadow of Mordor isn’t it.

  • Al Goodall

    I have a PS4 and I rather like it. I also have a fuckin great gaming PC that wipes the floor with my PS4. It doesn’t contain an APU nor would I ever buy one for a gaming PC build, most of us wouldn’t….Your a bit odd really.